Wednesday, March 3, 2010

I'm not nuts, I'm just...

A while back, I started following a great depression blog/forum called Beyond Blue. I've come to believe that depression is anorexia's bedfellow. They have a sort of codependent relationship. Like any relationship, I have to wonder, "Who's on top?" (Come on, you wonder this too). And, most of the time, I think it's depression. There are times when anorexia's gotten a little frisky, but depression is the dominant disease.

Yes, I see depression as a disease. There is great resistance to this idea, as shown by the ongoing battle over mental health parity in this country. The brain is part of the body, an organ just like the liver or heart (Carrie Arnold just did a great post titled "The brain is a body part," by the way). I don't pretend that I could control my liver's daily function, but I like to think I can control my brain. Most of us do, probably because an inability to control our brains is pretty frightening. I never really considered that something was off in my head. That was crazy, literally. For me, I just thought certain depressive traits were part of who I was. It went with the whole brooding writer persona...or something.

There's a post today over at Beyond Blue called "Am I depressed or just deep?" The author writes about her childhood:

I believed, along with all the other adults in my life, that my melancholy and sensitivity were part of my "special" make-up, that they were gifts to celebrate, not neuroses to treat. And should I take meds that helped me laugh and play and design cool barrettes like the other girls, well, then I would lose my depth.

I understand what she's saying. We grow to see ourselves in a certain way and this becomes our identity. We'll go to great lengths to protect that identity. We'll rationalize until we're blue in the face. I shoved aside the idea of "depression" and thought of myself as just philosophical, sensitive, smart enough to acknowledge realities like mortality and write bad poetry about them. There was a sense of superiority in my outlook. I protected the depression, in a way, by thinking of myself as more aware than other people, not so easily amused by simple pleasures like reality TV. I was above all that...and, well, not very happy.

The thing with mental illnesses is that they come with built-in self-protection mechanisms. There's a lot of stigma about mental illness, so we try our hardest to avoid that diagnosis, to fend it off. With anorexia, it's gotten really easy, considering all the focus on "health" in our society. Restrictions hide behind various causes and movements. I'm not anorexic, I'm just for animal rights. I'm not anorexic, I just want to support organic farming. I'm not anorexic, I just think preservatives and artificial ingredients cause cancer. I'm not anorexic, I'm just allergic to processed foods (yes, I've heard this). It wasn't really like this when I developed anorexia, though there were anti-fat and anti-carb frenzies to "help" my cause a bit. Still, I was the queen of excuses. I blamed weight loss on walking across campus, on a busy schedule, on "forgetting" to eat, on an out-of-whack metabolism.

Why do we look for alternate reasons like this? I think it's because if we were to admit the true issue -- depression, anorexia, whatever -- we'd have to, you know, do something about it. And that part -- doing something about it -- kind of sucks.

I've found myself saying lots of things like this: I don't need to go to therapy; I just need more hot baths. I don't need medication; I just need to learn to meditate. I have to think the reason mental health parity is so difficult is because those of us with mental health issues continue to think we can self-treat our brains. It's not just health insurance companies that don't want to acknowledge mental health problems; it's us. Even though I take medication for depression, I still find myself judgmental toward mental illness. I still hear that voice in my head that says, "Oh, come on, just snap out of it." I still criticize pharmaceutical companies for getting rich off creating demand for pills. And I still refrain from mentioning to people in my "real life" that I've struggled with any of this stuff.

What is your view of mental illnesses, like depression, anxiety or eating disorders? Do you have compassion, judgment, or both?

***
Today's gratitude:

1. All of you "Sliding Doors" and Gwyneth Paltrow fans. Who knew? I'm right there with you. I love that movie, and love her.

2. Weekend plans in the making: Potential blogger meet-up on Saturday, shopping with mom, and writer chat/Starbucks outing on Sunday. And I thought I was antisocial...

3. Trader Joe's frozen yogurt. This stuff is really good, and there are so many good topping combinations (I had it with granola last night). I highly recommend it.

4. Free car servicing. I had no idea that when you lease a car, they do all the maintenance checks at no charge.

5. Hump day.

15 comments:

Frugalista said...

I believe that depression is a disease. Nothing ticks me off more then to hear someone think it's something you can "snap out of" or just "get over." Who wants to be sad and miserable? Who would do that on purpose? As for getting your servicing free when you have a lease...it totally depends on the company. I had a jeep and I only wish I had gotten some free oil changes out of the deal!!

Maggie said...

Okay, this is creepy - are we the same person?
"I don't need to go to therapy; I just need more hot baths. I don't need medication; I just need to learn to meditate."
How many times have I said these EXACT two things in the last week?? I can't even count. I agree that my depression/bi-polarism/anxiety/whatever it is is way way worse than anorexia has ever been. I have been on 2 different meds (xanax and zoloft) but I'm not on anything now and I definitely need to be. The xanax helped but only by knocking me out so that I couldn't feel anything (that was a short term solution). The zoloft actually did nothing.

Unfortunately I don't have (enough) compassion (both for myself and others). I've been wanting to try cognitive therapy but I get too frustrated (I have hope that this would really work if I could stick to it).

I used to read Beyond Blue but for some reason stopped. I'll have to stop over there again.

fancythatfancythis.com said...

I'll admit that in the past I haven't been very patient with a few family members who are depressed. I guess because I don't fully understand depression and having never been depressed myself, I find it hard to relate. That being said, I am really making an effort to understand a little bit better and in the process I think I becoming more patient overall.

Free car servicing...I learned the hard way that it doesn't come with every leased car. Audi's are one example!

chezjulie said...

I wouldn't discount that great motivator SHAME either. If you admit that you have such-and-such a problem, you have to acknowledge the fact that you don't have things under control and you might need help.

I wore my "Yay Serotonin" T-shirt to Whole Foods on Sunday, and the young lady at the deli counter looked kind of stunned and touched. She told me she liked my shirt and could relate to it. This being "out" thing is kinda fun.

I Hate to Weight said...

i'm so glad to have medication, although i resisted it until i was 42. i clearly need it to get on with my life. lexapro is supposed to help anxiety, and i sure can have lots of that!

kim, what you wrote about looking at everything but the real issue somehow lead me to the whole childhood obesity issue--(hope i don't digress too much here) we're not looking at one of the biggest issues -- what's going on with the child's emotional and mental state? whis is he or she eating enough to be obese and sitting inside watching tv all afternoon? how is he or she being treated by peers?

there's a bigger problem than switching to lowfat milk and eating more fruit. healthiness is great -- physical AND mental.

off my soapbox. great post, kim!

sprinkledwithcinnamon said...

Denial and excuses- definitely feel it. I definitely used all those excuses when I had anorexia- and especially the 'out of whack' metabolism when my treatment team didn't see any weight gain progress- and that's probably why I kept relapsing- because everyone kept falling for all my excuses, all my denials. Change is a very difficult step to take- especially with mental illness, and especially if one has become so comfortable and used to having that illness/those symptoms that it just seems so foreign and terrifying to take the leap into the unknown.
I was literally forced into getting rid of my anorexia- I mean, ultimately it was my own decision whether I was going to cooperate and recover- but at first I really didn't have much of a choice and I'm thankful that I had parents and a treatment team who cared enough to make that exasperating effort.
I'm sure depression is no different- I really enjoyed this post.
Sara

love2eatinpa said...

well, this sounds horrible, but to be honest, until i realized a little over two years ago that i had an eating disorder, i wasn't very compassionate about mental disorders. now i totally get it.

so there is a silver lining - i have become more compassionate to my fellow sufferers.

Lou Lou said...

Depression and EDs go hand in hand, it feels like the chicken and the egg right?
hey heres a post to check out, I'd love to see your top 100!!!
http://jumpingcups.blogspot.com/2010/03/54-top-100-list.html

abbyhasissues said...

I'm with Maggie, in that I could have written that myself. My biggest excuse, one I still use all too often, is that I have "stomach issues." Yup. That's why I look the way I do, eat the way I do and exercise the way I do. My rationale...

I also know that my depression is the key issue, but I often wonder about the chicken or the egg thing (always egg for me, as you know, I don't eat meat). Am I depressed because of the anxiety/being underweight or because of the anxiety/being underweight am I depressed? I have a hard time believing that it's chemical--something out of my control--and I just want there to be something to "fix" it that's easy and clear.

Right. Oddly enough, I have empathy for those that suffer from mental illness like depression, etc. but absolutely no patience for those with "typical" eating disordered behaviors. I know that makes no sense, but I regard EDs without depression, anxiety, etc.--more about vanity and social ideals--with more disdain. I hate this about me, but I'm working on it.

moretolifethanlettuce said...

SO TRUE!

"the reason mental health parity is so difficult is because those of us with mental health issues continue to think we can self-treat our brains" it really is the people with mental illnesses who harbor the most irrational beliefs about mental illness! the most stigma comes from people who suffer from it, but aren't willing to completely accept/address it. so glad you wrote this post. depression and EDs are diseases just the same way that any somatic disease is. the brain and body are NOT separate, it's taken me a long time to understand that. oh and it would totally freak me out if people searched for my name and found my blog, you're brave! that's why i go by a pseudonym ;)

THE ACTORS DIET said...

as someone who's gone through it, goes through it, i know that it's a disease. and the people who don't get it can't get because they're not going through it.

Katie said...

It took me a very long time to accept that mental illnesses were in fact illnesses. Actually I don't think I applied that to everyone, just myself! Other people with depression, anxiety and eating disorders were ill and deserved sympathy, I should just pull myself together and stop being 'weak'. It didn't help that I got the same message from certain members of my family when I was younger - people who had also suffered from mental health problems and felt that I should keep quiet and live with it instead of getting help. Like Stef said, it's often people WITH these illnesses who have funny ideas about them, because they have made sense of their experience a certain way and now try to apply that to everyone. Like some girls I've come across who are in recovery from anorexia and insist that everyone with the disorder just has to learn to love their body. Sorry guys, I didn't have much of a problem with mine in the first place :P Most of the general public don't believe that anorexia is an illness either, because all they see is the symptom - the weight loss - and they imagine that a person would only do that if they believed that being emaciated was attractive. Education about the biology of mental illness would go a long way towards reducing stigma.

I think this can go too far in the opposite direction too though. It's far too common over here for people to think of anorexia as incurable, and for the health care system to leave people in a state of chronic illness. People with eating disorders are treatment resistent because that's a symptom of the illness, that doesn't mean they should be given up on. I don't get why mental illness as a treatable disease is such a difficult concept for people to get their heads around!

Carrie Arnold said...

Kim,

I have said similar things to myself SO MANY TIMES! I think our brains do try to protect ourselves from the crazies (or at least, that's what I call them!).

I might have to blog on this more later.

Also- I love Sliding Doors and I think I'm going to have to try and find it at the video store or library. Also just put TJ's fro yo on my list. First up, though, I want to make another batch of ice cream in my ice cream maker (best! invention! ever!)

Jessie said...

I have such a double standard when it comes to mental illness. Like Katie said, I see everyone else with depression and eating disorders and other mental illness as having illness that are biologically based and not their fault. I just can't apply that to myself. I'm always telling myself that if I just got it together somehow I would stop being depressed and I could just make the eating disordered thoughts magically disappear. But I don't expect anyone else to do that.

Ashley said...

i'm grateful for your post. at this point i don't care if someone finds out its me. kinda like the day i hit the rooms of aa. i want to stop, but i can't stop on my own. i need to ask for help. i'm glad i'm sober now that i can see the underneath problem...
ty. ash